
Hi, Please find my comments/questions below. Thanks in advance for your replies. Best regards, JMC. Orange Restricted De : Manrs-community <manrs-community-bounces@elists.manrs.org> De la part de Andrei Robachevsky Envoyé : jeudi 8 juin 2023 10:01 À : Community MANRS <manrs-community@elists.manrs.org> Cc : manrs-steering-committee@elists.manrs.org Objet : [manrs-community] MANRS Readiness Scores to be made public Dear MANRS participants, While this only concerns the Network Operators program, this is an important milestone for the whole initiative. <JMC> Why only Network Operators program? IMHO, CDN and IXP SHOULD be also considered if such a milestone is decided: these 2 programs have the "same maturity" as the Network Operator program. </JMC> This change has been requested and discussed with the community with positive feedback. <JMC> When? No log of such a discussion ... did I miss something? If this is the MANRS meeting during RIPE meeting, it was not be possible to attend it remotely ... and no report of this meeting too. </JMC> The MANRS Steering Committee has reviewed and approved this plan. Since April 2022, the MANRS team have been providing MANRS participants enrolled in the Network Operator program with an individual, monthly conformance report to update them on any changes to their compliance to MANRS Actions. <JMC> Seems there are still issues with MANRS initiative management before publishing data: * A questionnaire regarding one of my company's subsidiary has been sent a long time ago ... but no reply * A ticket has been submitted to get access to a subsidiary's account ... but no reply </JMC> This July, the scores for Actions 2, 3, and 4 will be made public on the MANRS NetOps participants table (https://www.manrs.org/netops/participants/), replacing the tick marks next to the named Actions. We will be adding the MANRS Readiness Score for Action 1 at a later date. This change aligns with the community's objectives to: * Raise awareness of routing security problems and encourage the implementation of actions that can address them. * Improve transparency and credibility of the MANRS initiative. * Promote a culture of collective responsibility toward the security and resilience of the Internet's global routing system. Network Operator participants will continue to receive individual, monthly conformance reports with their scores and any changes to the scores since the previous report at the start of each month. These scores will be updated on the MANRS website on the 8th day of each month. You can read more about how the MANRS Readiness Scores are calculated and their meaning<https://observatory.manrs.org/#/about> in the description of the Measurement Framework. Should you have any questions, please let us know. I also included a short Q&A to address the most common questions. Regards, Andrei Robachevsky MANRS Secretariat Questions & Answers Q: What is the MANRS Readiness Score? A MANRS readiness score indicates the degree of conformance of a MANRS participant to a MANRS Action. For example, to measure what degree Filtering (Action 1) is implemented we count the number of routing incidents where the network was implicated and the duration. Based on these metrics a normalized score is calculated for Action 1 for a specified time. Learn more about how the MANRS Readiness Scores are calculated and their meaning<https://observatory.manrs.org/#/about> in the description of the Measurement Framework. Q: Where will the MANRS Readiness Scores be made publicly available? * On the MANRS website, the scores will replace the tick marks in the participants' table<https://www.manrs.org/netops/participants/> of the Network Operators program. * On the MANRS Observatory, the scores will continue to be available to participants via their account. Q: Whose MANRS Readiness Scores will be made public? MANRS participants who are a part of the Network Operators program will be the first to have their MANRS Readiness Scores made publicly available. These will replace the tick marks for Actions 2, 3, and 4. MANRS Readiness Scores for Action 1 will be shown at a later date. Q: How do these MANRS Readiness Scores differ from the scores I get in my monthly conformance report? These scores are the same. This new initiative is making these scores public to align with the MANRS objectives to promote a culture of collective responsibility toward the security and resilience of the Internet's global routing system and raise awareness of routing security problems and encourage the implementation of actions that can address them. Q: Why are the scores being made public? Publication of the MANRS Readiness Scores is an important step to improve credibility and transparency of the initiative. This has been requested by community members and the concept of making the MANRS Readiness Scores public was first proposed in 2021. Several steps have been made to improve the value of these scores, including adding these scores to the monthly conformance reports, validating incidents, and improving the quality of the data we use. We feel it's at a point now that the scores provide an accurate enough analysis of the compliance of a MANRS participant towards MANRS Actions 2, 3, and 4. We will continue to work to refine the accuracy of the score for Action 1 before making this public. Q: How often will the scores be updated? You will continue to receive your most up-to-date MANRS Readiness Scores at the beginning of every month. These scores will then be published on the MANRS website on the 8th day of every month. ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Ce message et ses pieces jointes peuvent contenir des informations confidentielles ou privilegiees et ne doivent donc pas etre diffuses, exploites ou copies sans autorisation. Si vous avez recu ce message par erreur, veuillez le signaler a l'expediteur et le detruire ainsi que les pieces jointes. Les messages electroniques etant susceptibles d'alteration, Orange decline toute responsabilite si ce message a ete altere, deforme ou falsifie. Merci. This message and its attachments may contain confidential or privileged information that may be protected by law; they should not be distributed, used or copied without authorisation. If you have received this email in error, please notify the sender and delete this message and its attachments. As emails may be altered, Orange is not liable for messages that have been modified, changed or falsified. Thank you.