Hi Jean-Michel,

Why only Network Operators program?

IMHO, CDN and IXP SHOULD be also considered if such a milestone is decided: these 2 programs have the “same maturity” as the Network Operator program.

The Network Operators programme has tangible and regularly updated readiness scores for each of its Actions, and the Observatory (from where this data is generated) is primarily based on this programme. 

The IXP and Vendors programmes have different Actions and do not currently have readiness scores to determine conformance because they’re largely about implementation of technical and organisational policy.

On the CDN/Cloud programme this is a good suggestion and we can look at rolling this out next.

When?

No log of such a discussion … did I miss something?

If this is the MANRS meeting during RIPE meeting, it was not be possible to attend it remotely … and no report of this meeting too.

It has been discussed in various community meetings (e.g. at RIPE and APRICOT) and by the Steering Committee over the last year or so. There has been significant support for doing this and really no objections to publishing data that can already be found the public domain. 

Do you have any specific concerns with publishing this data?

Seems there are still issues with MANRS initiative management before publishing data:

  • A questionnaire regarding one of my company’s subsidiary has been sent a long time ago … but no reply
  • A ticket has been submitted to get access to a subsidiary’s account … but no reply
Okay, apologies for this. We’re looking back at the tickets and will contact you off-list.

Regards,

Kevin